Sasakawa Peace Foundation

日本語
  • About SPF
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • History
      • Program Policy and Five Priority Goals
      • Board Members
      • Diversity and Inclusion
      • Financial Position
      • Honorary Chair's Message Archive
      • Activities Before 2017
    • President's Message
    • Brochure and Annual Report
    • Access
    • Idea Submission
    • Careers
    • Contact Us
  • Experts
  • Programs
    • Japan-U.S. and Security Studies Unit
    • General Affairs and Networking Program
    • National Security and Japan-U.S. Program
    • Strategy and Deterrence Program
    • Asia and Middle East Unit
    • Strategic Dialogue and Exchange Program
    • Peacebuilding Program
    • Social Innovation Program
    • Sasakawa Japan-China Friendship Program
    • Ocean Policy Research Institute
    • Division of Ocean Vision and Action
    • Division of Island Nations
    • Scholarship Unit
    • Sasakawa Scholarship Program
  • Research & Analysis
    • Reports and Publications
    • Essays and Commentary
    • SPF Now Interviews
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Browse by Regions
    • Regions
    • Americas
    • Northeast Asia
    • Southeast Asia
    • South Asia
    • Middle East
    • Oceania
    • Europe and Eurasia
    • Arctic
    • Africa
    • Satellite Sites
    • International Information Network Analysis
    • SPF China Observer
    • Asia Women Impact Fund
    • The OPRI Center of Island Studies
    • The Friends of WMU, Japan
    • SPF Insights into Japan–U.S. Relations
    • From the Oceans
    • Asia Peacebuilding Initiatives (APBI)
    • History of the Sasakawa Japan-China Friendship Program
      (Japanese language)
    • Japan-China Relations Data Graph (Japanese language)
  • News
    • News
    • Press Releases
    • SPF Newsletter
    • Media Coverage
  • Events
SPF NOW

China's Belt and Road Initiative in Context

Interview with Abigail Grace, Research Associate at the Center for a New American Security (CNAS), and Dr. Kei Koga, Assistant Professor at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore

By Jackie Enzmann, Chief Editor


November 19, 2018
Following the expert seminar addressing China's Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) organized by the Sasakawa Peace Foundation's (SPF) Japan-US Program, SPF Now had the opportunity to meet with the featured experts to take a closer look at topics ranging from infrastructure investment to great power politics.

Abigail Grace, Research Associate at the Center for a New American Security (CNAS), discussed her expectations for the potential implementation of the policies presented in the report "Power Play," which she coauthored, and touched on broader geopolitical shifts in the Indo-Pacific region and around the world. Dr. Kei Koga, Assistant Professor at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore, elaborated on his research into the reception of BRI policies in Southeast Asia, the potential role of Japan in the region, and the impressions of the Trump administration and its policies.

Below are excerpts from those two interviews, which were conducted separately. Comments have been arranged according to topic and edited for length and clarity.

Multilateral policy approach presented in "Power Play"

CNAS Research Associate Abigail Grace

Abigail Grace: It's important for the U.S. to remember that any endeavor that it pursues regionally is always better when it cooperates with allies and partners such as Japan and others in the region. If we truly want to stand up for the values and systems and institutions that have benefitted both the U.S. and Japan so much throughout the past decades, it's important that we collaborate, listen to one another, and build mutually reinforcing approaches.

Frequently when the United States is engaged in more direct competition with China, China likes to portray the U.S. as pursuing its own hegemonic ambitions when in fact that's not the case at all. Instead, it's in the collective interest of Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and a host of other regional partners who also ascribe to the same laws and norms that we uphold these systems and values together. If we're all working in tandem with one another, that cuts away at China's most credible or perhaps most potent criticism of U.S. actions in the region. I am also a big believer in the fact that people who live in the region and have perhaps a more immediate vested stake than many Americans will identify more creative solutions because they're on the ground facing the problems every day.
Dr. Kei Koga: From a Japanese perspective, what the report "Power Play" says is completely understandable, and Japan generally welcome this kind of multilateral initiative. At the same time, Japan takes a different approach to BRI than the United States. While the U.S. has a tougher stance toward BRI and tends to pursue a more competitive strategy, Japan actually takes a softer approach to shape China's behavior, utilizing its knowledge about the current state of projects in Southeast Asia.

Dr. Kei Koga, Assistant Professor at Nanyang Technological University

I think BRI is basically a good thing for Southeast Asian countries' infrastructure development, so they want to cooperate with the Chinese government. But if the U.S. tried to take a competitive approach toward the Chinese BRI, that wouldn't be good for Southeast Asian countries because they are afraid of being in the middle of great power politics. This fear is derived from their experiences before and during the Cold War when great powers' intervention in Southeast Asia infringed on the regional political autonomy.

Also, there is a negative side to BRI itself. For example, Indonesia has the Jakarta-Bandung high speed railway project, which was conducted by the Chinese, but because the bankability and feasibility were very low, the project has been stalled for a long time. This type of implementation problem persists in the BRI projects and demonstrates a negative side of Chinese investment. Southeast Asian countries welcome the financial aid, but at the same time want to ensure that the projects are actually realized.

The report says that the United States is going to have a more coordinated policy toward BRI, which would be good for Southeast Asian countries as long as the U.S. cooperates with China and China adheres to the same principles and guidelines as the United States and Japan do. If properly executed, I think Southeast Asian countries are more assured that it's not going to end up as a completely competitive strategy, which is good for Southeast Asian countries.

(2) >>

Share

Related Articles

Latest News

SPF NOW

Interview with Vincent Pala, Member of Parliament for Shillong, Meghalaya state, India

As India looks to deepen ties with Japan and other countries through its Act East policy, Northeast India — a diverse region composed of eight states — has become a key gateway from India to Southeast Asia and beyond. SPF spoke with Vincent Pala, a member of parliament representing Shillong in the state of Meghalaya, to discuss the significance of international exchanges and expectations for future collaboration between Japan and India.

January 25, 2024
SPF NOW

Interview with Commodore Peter Olive, Head of Futures and Strategic Analysis at the Defence, Concepts and Doctrine Centre (DCDC)

SPF Senior Research Fellow Ippeita Nishida spoke with the Head of Futures and Strategic Analysis for DCDC, Commodore Peter Olive, about the relevance of the GST in the face of unexpected shocks from the COVID-19 pandemic to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, as well as his thoughts on the shifting dynamics across the strategic landscape in the Indo-Pacific looking toward the next 30 years.

February 13, 2023
SPF NOW

Interview with Dr. Ufuk Ulutaş, Chairman of Center for Strategic Research, and Dr. Mesut Özcan, Director of Diplomacy Academy, Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Türkiye

Dr. Ulutaş and Dr. Özcan sat down with SPF to discuss the unique position of Türkiye within the Ukraine conflict, current Japan-Türkiye relations, and possible areas to deepen this partnership, including potential cooperation on defense issues.

November 14, 2022
Browse Latest News

pagetop

Video Title

Footer

Sasakawa Peace Foundation

  • About SPF
  • News
  • Experts
  • Events
  • Programs
  • Access
  • Research & Analysis
  • Contact Us

Latest Updates

Receive regular updates about news, events, and research from the Sasakawa Peace Foundation

Sign Up to Our Newsletter

Satellite Sites

  • From the Oceans
  • The Friends of WMU Japan
  • Asia Women Impact Fund
  • Insights into Japan–U.S. Relations
  • International Information Network Analysis (IINA)
  • The OPRI Center of Island Studies
  • SPF China Observer
  • Asia Peacebuilding Initiatives (APBI)
  • History of the Sasakawa Japan-China Friendship Program (Japanese language)
  • Japan-China Relations Data Graph (Japanese language)
  • PRIVACY POLICY
  • SITE POLICY
  • SOCIAL MEDIA POLICY
  • SITE MAP
  • WEB ACCESSIBILITY POLICY

Copyright © 2021 The Sasakawa Peace Foundation. All Rights Reserved.